Why buy a whole pie when you can enjoy individually-sized pieces of so many different flavors? Of course you can buy a whole pie, but there’s some fun in trying different flavors, right? Pies from Mr. Dye’s Pies run the spectrum from the most popular and common flavors to creative (but still delicious) concoctions. Some flavor options include Key-Lime, Classic Sweet Potato, Brandy Old Fashioned Cherry, Nawlins’ Pecan and Purple Monster. In addition to generously-sized individual slices and whole pies, half pies are also available.
Owner Johnathan Dye first brought his baked creations to HarborMarket four years ago. You’ll occasionally find “Mr. Dye” himself at his booth, while other times you’ll find a member of his highly knowledgeable staff. Based in Milwaukee, Mr. Dye’s Pies has been featured in local media, including Milwaukee area television stations! Find Mr. Dye’s Pies on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter.